Quiz night!

You are brewing a 14-15 SRM hoppy beer. You have two water choices with limited information. Here they are:

Water #1:
Total hardness 110
Alkalinity CaC03 110

Water #2:
Total hardness 200
Alkalinity CaC03 125

Both have a pH of 7.1

Which do you use and what changes do you make?

Use #1, add 1/2 tsp Gypsum.