I can’t help but laugh. I’m a new brewer and just bottled the Innkeeper Wed of last week. It was my 4th batch. Before that my yeast strains went as such:
Thames Valley
05
05
the Innkeeper dry yeast option - Danstar Nottingham Ale
I know this doesn’t really have anything to do with your question but the first three yeast cakes were soft and sludgy in appearance and consistency. I had to hold the auto siphon up off the cakes so as to not transfer a bunch of crap to the bottling bucket, but when I was transferring my Innkeeper I was surprised at the fact I just dropped the auto siphon down into the bottom of the bucket and didn’t get a lot of junk. Clear as a whistle.
When I got all the beer out I realized that the Danstar Nottingham Ale yeast produced a different kind of cake than the first 3 beers. It seemed almost hard, and even when tipping the bucket to get those last drops of beer out, it didn’t ‘run’ towards the low side. It also looked like a bunch of bumps with holes in them. Reminded me of barnacles on a pier piling or something. It washed out fine but I actually liked the way it was somewhat stiff and hard (please no 'that’s what she said jokes… ha)
So anyway, that’s my Innkeeper story. Going to let her go till this coming weekend in the bottle before tasting her. Hope it turns out as well as most people say. Seems to be a popular kit.
As far as trub is concerned, after cooling to 80 degrees I pour my wort straight into the fermenting bucket that has a sanitized 5 gallon paint strainer in it. That helps to aerate the wort as well as get rid of all the crap I don’t want in there. I guess it’s a personal decision as some may like to ferment with all the trub from the boil.