Last year I bought a cooling paddle to try moving up from an ice water bath. It’s a large heavy duty plastic item used in many commercial kitchens to cool down soup at the end of the day. I brew three gallon batches and thought the 64 oz. one would work; I was wrong. I was able to get a three gallon pot of 200f water only down into the 160s. I then went to my LHBS (Bader Brewing) and bought a 20’ x 3/8" IC. It took my last batch (pilsner) down to 55f in 20 minutes. I used the cooling paddle to get it down a couple more, put it in the cooler for an hour and pitched the yeast at 52f.
I wish I’d bought an I C years ago.