Dare I ask: Can we say “balance”? Thoughts of any sort? Constructive criticism very welcome…
Hopville Link: http://hopville.com/recipe/1664693
% LB OZ
72% 9 0 Rahr 2-row Pale
8% 1 0 Victory Malt
8% 1 0 Rice Hulls
8% 1 0 Briess Caramel 20L
4% 0 8 Briess Caramel 40L
boil 20 min 1oz Warrior
boil 10 min 1oz Crystal
boil 10 min 1oz Simcoe
boil 5 min 2oz Crystal
boil 1 min 2oz Mt. Hood
dry hop 5 day 1oz Crystal
dry hop 5 day 1oz Mt. Hood
Wyeast American Ale II (1272)
yeast in form with high flocculation and 74% attenuation
1.061 OG (1.055 to 1.064)
1.016 FG (1.014 to 1.017)
Alcohol 6% ABV 5% ABW
Calories201 per 12 oz.
Looks pretty good, personally I would drop the Victory as I like my IPA’s simple. Usually about 10% Crystal and 2 row with 1:1 BU:GU which you are spot on for. Also unless your system really requires it you shouldnt need rice hulls for a simple batch like that. All they do is suck up precious wort IMO.
I would never brew anything over 200 calories/12oz.
That is quite a bit of color malt for an American IPA. I would go with 10% crystal max. I love Victory malt in a brown ale, but I don’t know how it will work with the pineapple character of Simcoe. I definitely think balance is important in an IPA. It does need some malt character, but the hops should be the star in an American IPA. I also don’t think you need the rice hulls unless you are pulverizing your malt or had a stuck mash with your system in the past.
I used 0.5 lb of biscuit in my last IPA and that worked wonders. Of course that goes away from american a bit but I only used half a pound…
It’s interesting to me how different people have different tastes. I would be tempted to cut out the crystal malt altogether or at the very least use nothing more than 20L and not very much of that at all. Of course, I generally try to dry out almost every beer I make. The Dogfish Head 60 clone I make has base 2 row and a bit of brown malt and that’s it. I also really like a bit of biscuit, especially in English brews, it adds some interest. I also agree, you shouldn’t need the rice hulls but I always keep some around just in case bad stuff happens.
As far as hops go, Crystal and Mt Hood are awfully mellow for a style like this, don’t you want the traditional chewing on a pine tree/grapefruit flavor? Warrior is a great choice for a bittering hop, I have had very good luck with it.
Any good resources I can use/visit to learn about what type of hop results in what type of hop flavors?
Me too, but I found a touch of victory really helped an ordinary bitter recipe that I wasn’t happy with.
I’d definitely drop some of the specialty malts. i would limit the victory and crystal mix 10% or less
the mix of that much crystal and victory will leave you with a sweet finish that might combat your hops in a unpleasant way.
why rice hulls?
Bad joke man. I’ve never even considered calories when brewing.
Bad joke man. I’ve never even considered calories when brewing.[/quote]
Or drinking. Or eating.