Thanks Rusty.
I got to the bottom of it, kind of.
I purchased a refractometer. I used it to measure the OG of 1.073, which was right on top of my target. After 10 days of fermentation, took another reading with the refractometer. Reading was 1.050, so backed in to an ABV of around 5%,which had me scratching my head. I figured adding the cherry juice must have increased the gravity by a LOT but left a lot of unfermentables.
Fast forward to tonight. Took another gravity reading using my buddy’s hydrometer (broke mine, which was the whole reason I bought the refractometer) and it was 1.020, so an ABV around 8.25%, which was pretty much my initial expectation.
I know you have to adjust a refractometer for FG readings because of the alcohol present, but that difference seems crazy to me. I think a normal adjustment is a factor of like 4% (not 60%).
Going to have to read up on my new gadget, but I calibrated it with water, and worried I have a defective unit.
In any event,thanks again for your response!
Cheers,
Drew