I’m starting to harvest yeast and just pitched half the cake from my cream ale into my mutts nuts. The yeast was very active and my og was 1.052, higher than the 1.043 called for. So will Safale 05 be much different than the Safale 04? Wort was at 62 at pitching.
Us-05 is a clean fermenting yeast some say capable of fermenting any style. Where Us-04 is a English yeast and will produce little fruity esters. You will be alright it will just be a little cleaner and less esters both are great yeast.